The book puts forward the important argument that brutal mass killings under. In addition, naimark compares stalins crimes with those of the most notorious genocidal killer of them all, adolf hitler. Millions more fell victim to forced labor, deportation, famine, bloody massacres, and detention and interrogation by stalin s henchmen. Stalin, perpetrator of the multiple examples behind the book s plural title. I decided, then, to write this book about stalin s genocides, making the argument that what happened in the 30s, this terrible mass killing, was genocide. Historian norman naimark argues that todays narrow definition of genocide is stalins lasting legacy.
Naimark, author of the controversial new book stalins genocides, argues that we need a much broader definition of genocide, one that includes nations killing social classes and political groups. The book puts forward the important argument that brutal mass killings under stalin in. We need a much broader definition of genocide, one that includes nations killing social classes and political groups. Blood and soil is an important and courageous attempt to write a world history of genocide from sparta to darfur. Millions more died from forced labour, deportation, starvation, and labour camps or. Stalin, perpetrator of the multiple examples behind the books plural title. The book puts forward the important argument that brutal mass kill between the early 1930s and his death in 1953, joseph stalin had more than a million of his own citizens executed.
Europe between hitler and stalin as well as stalins genocides. He looks at the most consequential and harrowing episodes of stalin s systematic destruction of his own populacethe liquidation and repression of the socalled kulaks, the ukrainian famine, the purge of nationalities, and the great terrorand examines them in light of other genocides in history. But stanford historian norman naimark looks at stalin s mass killings and urges that the. Norman naimark, one of our most respected authorities on the soviet era, challenges the widely held notion that stalin s crimes do not constitute genocide, which the. In his excellent recent book stalins genocides, stanford historian norman naimark argues that joseph stalin committed genocide and not merely mass murder. Genocide occurs in every time period and on every continent. Dec 25, 2011 norman naimark s extended essay stalin s genocides is both controversial and provocative. Sep 23, 2010 naimark, author of the controversial new book stalin s genocides, argues that we need a much broader definition of genocide, one that includes nations killing social classes and political groups. He looks at the most consequential and harrowing episodes of stalins systematic destruction of his own. What is not well established is what to call stalin s crimes. Stalins genocides human rights and crimes against humanity book 8 kindle edition by norman m.
Stalins genocides norman m naimark haftad 9780691152387. Norman naimark, one of our most respected authorities on the soviet era. This argument is made more difficult by the fact that there was no single act of genocide in the soviet case, but rather a series of interrelated attacks on class enemies and enemies of. The book puts forward the important argument that brutal mass killings under stalin in the 1930s were indeed acts of genocide and that the soviet. Stalins genocides norman m naimark bok 9780691147840.
Few any longer deny that stalins regime slaughtered millions of innocent people. Stalins genocides is the chilling story of these crimes. For naimark, labeling stalins mass killing genocide entails a rigorous exegesis of the concept itself its history, legal complexities, boundaries, and universe. Stalin s genocides an analysis and opinion piece about marxist leninist genocide and massmurder in the soviet union addeddate 20150214 21. Between the early 1930s and his death in 1953, joseph stalin had more than a. Providing an indispensable resource for students and policy makers investigating the bosnian catastrophes of the 1990s, this book provides a comprehensive survey of the leaders, ideas, movements, and events pertaining to one of the most devastating conflicts of contemporary times. Stalins genocides is compellingly written, nuanced and powerfully argued. Norman naimarks extended essay stalins genocides is both controversial and provocative.
Between the early 1930s and his death in 1953, joseph stalin had more than a million of his own citizens executed. The chilling story of stalin s crimes against humanity. Sep 23, 2010 naimark, author of the controversial new book stalins genocides, argues that we need a much broader definition of genocide, one that includes nations killing social classes and political groups. Stalin, perpetrator of the multiple examples behind the book. Pdf on jun 1, 2012, lavinia stan and others published stalins genocides. The chilling story of stalins crimes against humanity. Snyder studies the people caught between hitlers germany and stalins russia, suffering two and sometimes three wartime occupations. He looks at the most consequential and harrowing episodes of stalin\s systematic destruction of his own populacethe liquidation and repression of the socalled kulaks, the ukrainian famine, the purge of nationalities, and the great terrorand examines them in light of other genocides in history. Dec 25, 2011 the book puts forward the important argument that brutal mass killings under stalin in the 1930s were indeed acts of genocide and that the soviet dictator himself was behind them. Stalins genocides human rights and crimes against humanity. Princeton, new jersey, princeton university press, 2010. Simon sebag montefiore, author of young stalin and stalin. But the russian government and some western writers continue to argue that these murders were not genocidal, and that stalin therefore cannot be. The book puts forward the important argument that brutal mass killings under stalin in the 1930s were indeed acts of genocide and that the soviet dictator himself was behind them.
Ethnic cleansing in twentiethcentury europe, among others, uses stalins crimes as a lens with which to examine the nature and, indeed, the very meaning, of the idea of genocide. In total, stalin is responsible for the murder of roughly 10 million soviet citizens. This short bookreally an extended essayis intended to argue that stalins mass killings of the 1930s should be classified as genocide. Naimark has been awarded the officers cross of the order of merit by germany. Naimarks daring effort to redefine several of the crimes committed by stalins regime in the 1930s and 1940s as acts of genocide is admirable.
Yet naimark reveals a surprisingly flexible stalin, who initially had no intention of dividing europe. Home genocide studies research guides at community. She calls naimark s argument authoritative, clear, and hard to dispute. Jan 26, 2012 stalin s genocides is a magisterial and admirably lucid analysis of the stalinist terrors that is both totally accessible and finely nuanced in its scholarship naimark s superb work assigns the criminality to stalin s own bizarre personality as well as the repressive soviet system.
Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading stalins genocides human rights and crimes against humanity book 8. Stalin s genocides an analysis and opinion piece about marxist leninist genocide and massmurder in the soviet union. Naimark has 21 books on goodreads with 1499 ratings. Naimark, author of the new book stalins genocides princeton university press, 2010, argues that the world needs a much broader definition of genocide that includes nations killing social classes and political groups. During the two decades before his death in 1953, stalin perpetrated unspeakable crimes. Naimark lucidly shows that genocide both changes over time, depending on the character of major historical periods, and remains the same in. Peter robinson sits down with naimark to discuss his latest book, genocide. Perspectives on norman naimarks stalins genocides mit press. As norman naimark points out in his thoughtprovoking stalin s genocides princeton up, 2010, historians and others have been peculiarly conflicted about this issue. Sep 22, 2010 when it comes to use of the word genocide, public opinion has been kinder to stalin than hitler.
Naimark s daring effort to redefine several of the crimes committed by stalin s regime in the 1930s and 1940s as acts of genocide is admirable. Many historians have argued that genocide is a form of mass killing that began only in the 20th century with the advent of the modernist state, extreme nationalist ideologies, mass media and. Stalins genocides human rights and crimes against humanity book 8 kindle edition by naimark, norman m download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. In a fitting inversion of his notorious personality cult, joseph stalin has been vilified with an array of explosive epithets since 1956from tyrant. For naimark, labeling stalin s mass killing genocide entails a rigorous exegesis of the concept itself its history, legal complexities, boundaries, and universe. He is a professor in the history department at stanford university, and a senior fellow at the hoover institution. Jul 19, 2010 between the early 1930s and his death in 1953, joseph stalin had more than a million of his own citizens executed. Millions more fell victim to forced labor, deportation, famine, bloody massacres, and detention and interrogation by stalins henchmen. That s when i got into issues of the definition of genocide, which you read at the beginning. Jul 19, 2010 stalins genocides ebook written by norman m. Stalin s genocides, written by norman m naimark princeton university press, 2010 logue library call number. Naimark s contention, in his controversial new book stalins genocides. Dec 25, 2011 stalin s genocides is compellingly written, nuanced and powerfully argued.
During a window of opportunity from 1945 to 1948, leaders across the political spectrum, including juho kusti paasikivi of finland, wladyslaw gomulka of poland, and karl renner of austria, pushed back against outside pressures. A history of the soviet zone of occupation, 19451949 and fires of hatred. The book is a timely and instructive account not merely of our own history but also of our fractious, unsettling present. But the russian government and some western writers continue to argue that these murders were not genocidal, and that stalin therefore. A volume in princetons series human rights and crimes against humanity, stalins genocides takes a look at the soviet dictators use of mass slaughter in pursuit of total mastery of the ussr, the soviet bloc, and the world communist. He looks at the most consequential and harrowing episodes of stalins systematic destruction of his own populacethe liquidation and repression of the socalled kulaks, the ukrainian famine, the purge of nationalities, and the great terrorand examines them in light of other genocides in history. Stalins genocides ebok norman m naimark 9781400836062.
Some lithuanians will see bloodlands and stalins genocides as proof of the theory of two genocides. Naimark and snyder are not antsemites nor is their intention to obfuscate, or minimize hitlers and stalins mass murders. Under stalin in the 1930s, more than a million soviet citizens were murdered. Thats when i got into issues of the definition of genocide, which you read at the beginning. Oct 11, 2017 norman naimark, senior fellow at the hoover institution and an expert on eastern europe and genocides throughout history, brings his considerable expertise to uncommon knowledge to discuss the. Naimark starts his book by declaring, stalins mass killings of the 1930s should be classified as genocide. Naimark s short book is a polemical contribution to this debate.
This short book really an extended essayis intended to argue that stalins mass killings of the 1930s should be classified as genocide. Naimark argues that genocides occur throughout history, from biblical to. By the same token, many of the atrocities committed in the soviet union under iosif stalin or in china under mao zedong would not be classed as genocide if the. In this gripping book, naimark explains how stalin became a pitiless mass killer. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read stalins genocides. In his new book, historian norman naimark argues that the definition of genocide should include nations killing social classes and political. The court of the red tsar this book is simply outstanding. Norman naimark, one of our most respected authorities on the soviet era, challenges the widely held notion that stalin s crimes do not constitute genocide, which the united nations defines as the premeditated killing of a group of people because of their race, religion, or inherent national qualities. The book puts forward the important argument that brutal mass killings under stalin in the 1930s were indeed acts of genocide and that the soviet dictator himself. Stalins genocides is a magisterial and admirably lucid analysis of the stalinist terrors that is both totally accessible and finely nuanced in its scholarshipnaimarks superb work assigns the criminality to stalins own bizarre personality as well as the repressive soviet system. Norman naimark, stalins genocides princeton up, 2010.
Stalin s genocides is the chilling story of these crimes. This is a small book that places a large exclamation point on the most incriminatingly tragic dimension of soviet history. Nor do they equate the crimes of nazism and communism, as some lithuanians would like. Nov 23, 2010 in his excellent recent book stalins genocides, stanford historian norman naimark argues that joseph stalin committed genocide and not merely mass murder. Please introduce ben kiernans book for us, and the genocides it covers.
Norman naimark, stalins genocides by marshall poe and. That definition, as you recall, says nothing about social groups. Millions more fell victim to forced labor, deportation, famine, bloody massacres. Norman m naimark between the early 1930s and his death in 1953, joseph stalin had more than a million of his own citizens executed. The book puts forward the important argument that brutal mass between the early 1930s and his death in 1953, joseph stalin had more than a million of his own citizens executed. Naimark stanford, author of the russians in germany.
1272 582 148 208 979 796 641 243 14 238 486 930 1285 570 1347 1383 1110 770 1153 51 523 1331 274 1371 1180 1423 688 1156 647 964 507 1188 188 1348 263 1313 159 1219 978 1198 400